wait is this true? https://x.com/fairy1aobao/status/1826616773539758162
They just made that up
it isn’t and members have acknowledged their sfs many times hell members have acknowledged another member’s sf publicly idk what they on
just unserious
oo criyangis sending trucks tomorrow about his parts & styling. the parts i do get but imo his styling has been better recently
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 I saw his fans tweaking over no lines in the album sampler they just can't recognize his voice it's crazy but wow did they reach the funding goal already if they're popping out tmrw
this subfandom has become so irking like what about his styling is bad??? i love it so much he's been looking good every single day like what? 😭
I guess that acc getting reported is common sentiment in China which I don't get cuz sorry Ricky looked a damn mess for almost 6 months......
i read the translations they don’t mention his clothes they wrote “is this professional hair and makeup? ricky doing it himself is better than this. Immediately improve your poor skills!” from what ive seen cfans in general hate when a lot of hairspray or that wet look is given to hair ive seen it in every fandom ive been in they think it looks greasy and idk what issue theyve had with makeup recently cuz its been looking better
I consider styling generally so I mean makeup clothes all of it. but it's actually about the makeup?? I thought it would be the sleeveless issue which would make sense since a lottt of other fans hate it for other members and Ricky definitely gets it the most. but that's ....interesting the wet look isn't too bad but genuinely Ricky has looked better now than he did months ago they rlly want him to start looking a mess again yuck
i thought abt it more and im thinking they might still be upset abt the makeup he had for keep running and some other schedules cuz big cent accounts were dragging him for heavy makeup a lot of his fans do prefer more natural makeup in certain contexts and also balloon helped them write the statements for the trucks so i guess it somewhat reflects kfan opinion too
I can agree on that they put Ricky in the heaviest makeup out of the group and I've always loved the lighter look on him but a truck 😅😅😅😅 but if balloons in on it I guess kfans agree on something maybe it's the line thing maybe it's the sleeveless styling ik they hate that too
Different aesthetic sense, all members' concept photos in the cinema were criticized on weibo because they didn't look like idols. Cfans really hate wet hair looks, that's their ick and Ricky has been constantly having wet hair and gelled it ever since he had black hair. They also hate it when idols exercise and wear tank tops
so what did they look like then.. NDNNFNFNND I mean they can go ahead they wanna nerf Ricky they can do it
no offense but why did his cfans stan him in the first place? Almost every BP ep he had that wet hair gel look and it's clearly a style he likes and does himself cause even in his predebut pics he had that wet hair gel style... can they just fuck off and unstan him I'm so serious cause they wanna turn him into a flower boy like yujins pink princess cfans
that's what I'm tryna understand like they're actually creating problems up in their heads
wait is this true? https://x.com/fairy1aobao/status/1826616773539758162
They just made that up
that is notttt true 😭 i follow all the members on pluschat and several of them have mentioned their sf name offhandedly it's normal especially since they've all had sfs since before debut
Like they deadass made that up I'm crying
wait is this true? https://x.com/fairy1aobao/status/1826616773539758162
They just made that up
ngl at the end of the day idk why you are surprised cbars are boycotting when wk1 is fumbling everything and giving basically nothing to 3 of the 4 most popular members 😭😭😭 like why should their fans keep funding the hanbin jiwoong gyuvin matthew show
Its just as much the hao show and the yujin show too like what’re u even talking ab im crying ik we dog on gyuvin here but please explain to me how hes getting served more than those two yall dont have to make things up to make sense of things that just happen and we move on lmao that's not true at all 😭
I saw yujin's cbar boycotting yesterday like I'm sorry this guy is currently getting pushed as main vocal, main dancer, main center, main mc main everything I'm crying what do his fans even have to complain about this guy gets more lines than TAERAE sometimes 😭
yujins cbar has rocks for brains but it's more about his health which again a statement was released about so idk what more they want
juyeon is the best 🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤…
he needs some suckleyanggg
https://x.com/ahnwana/status/1826847368895176828 k wakeone actually stupid and sabotaging us atp cuz only hardcore fans will willingly open this shitty laggy ass app 😭 WHY NOT STREAM ON YOUTUBE WHERE IT HAS A HIGHER CHANCE FOR THE GP TO TUNE IN OMFG LIKE WHY THEY TRYNA FIX SOMETHING THAT AINE BROKE
It is streaming on YouTube
i dont remember if we ever have this much views for prev cb but 20k for good so bad 😭😭😭😭 things are looking up for jebes https://www.instiz.net/name_enter/93208294
These are really good numbers for instiz I can't say for sure how previous posts did but in general these r good numbers
we had like 100 ftp marple posts and I've only seen at least 5 marple posts for good so bad so its definitely up for us 📈📈📈📈📈📈📈
they was getting tore tf up for ftp wow zb1 rlly were ab to die for that
oo criyangis sending trucks tomorrow about his parts & styling. the parts i do get but imo his styling has been better recently
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 I saw his fans tweaking over no lines in the album sampler they just can't recognize his voice it's crazy but wow did they reach the funding goal already if they're popping out tmrw
this subfandom has become so irking like what about his styling is bad??? i love it so much he's been looking good every single day like what? 😭
I guess that acc getting reported is common sentiment in China which I don't get cuz sorry Ricky looked a damn mess for almost 6 months......
i read the translations they don’t mention his clothes they wrote “is this professional hair and makeup? ricky doing it himself is better than this. Immediately improve your poor skills!” from what ive seen cfans in general hate when a lot of hairspray or that wet look is given to hair ive seen it in every fandom ive been in they think it looks greasy and idk what issue theyve had with makeup recently cuz its been looking better
I consider styling generally so I mean makeup clothes all of it. but it's actually about the makeup?? I thought it would be the sleeveless issue which would make sense since a lottt of other fans hate it for other members and Ricky definitely gets it the most. but that's ....interesting the wet look isn't too bad but genuinely Ricky has looked better now than he did months ago they rlly want him to start looking a mess again yuck
i thought abt it more and im thinking they might still be upset abt the makeup he had for keep running and some other schedules cuz big cent accounts were dragging him for heavy makeup a lot of his fans do prefer more natural makeup in certain contexts and also balloon helped them write the statements for the trucks so i guess it somewhat reflects kfan opinion too
I can agree on that they put Ricky in the heaviest makeup out of the group and I've always loved the lighter look on him but a truck 😅😅😅😅 but if balloons in on it I guess kfans agree on something maybe it's the line thing maybe it's the sleeveless styling ik they hate that too
i feel like his makeup has been lighter recently than say months ago during award season though? anyways maybe they have specific complaints or something that we just don't see
I think so too!!!!! Like clearly they don't know what heavy makeup looks like.... but I think it's just a difference in taste but it's also a minor thing for the truck just kinda crazy that Ricky's getting styling complaints when he looks his best
Tbh I realized no matter how light his makeup is, he could just be wearing light foundation but if you put him next to the members people are still going to say he is wearing pounds makeup with contour and a baked face and that's because he has facial depth 😭 and because of it his face naturally creates more shadows and highlight are more noticeable compared to members with softer features. It also doesn't help that he naturally has thicker, darker brows and big lips. So muas can put the same shade and same amount of lip stick on him and say Hanbin but his lips would look 'heavy' as if he followed a kylie 10 step lip tutorial.
ur right like he could be on some bb cream and a little chapstick and he'd get accused what do they call that again a high weight face? yea he's got that
oo criyangis sending trucks tomorrow about his parts & styling. the parts i do get but imo his styling has been better recently
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 I saw his fans tweaking over no lines in the album sampler they just can't recognize his voice it's crazy but wow did they reach the funding goal already if they're popping out tmrw
pls no pls dont take this ricky away from me https://x.com/QualiaQuanrui/status/1820309364403782038 💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔 ill actually be so sad 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 but agree with the no lines like his tone is one of the prettiest for them not to utilize it properly unlike in ftp like take jiwoongs lines and give it to him
I think I'm understanding their point more but again a truck is so unnecessary and would also send the wrong message ugh his styling can't be nuked again there's a difference in opinion between the k and c side but idk like every other truck nothings gonna happen most likely
tbh nothing will happen unless they post the truck on twt and it gets engagement
noyb has that drafted tweet ready girl wym it's going to blow up
right cuz knowing wakeones history with trucks they're most likely just gonna disregard everything and keep doing what they want if they really cared they would've tooken action with the the millions of other trucks they received so there's really nothing to fret about imo and fuck nyob fr her a ttopaz get on my nerves so bad
Like sorry trucks do NOTTT work if they did we would've seen it but noyb and ttopaz are actually so tapped ik they're about to shake shit up soon in light of this
Woah that new Sabrina album mid as hell. I still don't get why her label and Sabrina herself don't realize that releasing songs like Espresso it's what it's going to keep her on stardom and now those slow tempo songs that she makes.
I saw her song with Jenna Ortega all over my fyp... NOT MOVED IN THE SLIGHTEST
where did this sentiment that zb1 have bad music even come from like do i glaze them too hard bc they're my ults or is their music really that horrible? 😭 like feel the pop is a bit of a miss but it's not bad and i don't really dislike it, it's just not a fav. yhmah is also a bit of a miss but that's about cohesion and not the actual songs for me bc yits and melpo have great cohesion (idk if cinema paradise will have that now that i judge the highlight medley but anyway). i know crush started it all but is that one section really that bad to completely discard the rest of the song? everyone being like "we're so back" and "congrats on your 2nd debut", saying that directly to the members like it's just crazy to me bc i love so much of their discography and they're the only newer group that's grabbed me i feel like i'm being gaslit LMAO
people do the most calling their music terrible its just another thing of the hate they get and people dog pilling. it's not shocking when people call it mid either it's not anything special and the members voices are the best parts of the songs rather than the song themselves but this mini is measuring up to be their best in every way by farrrrrrr but I definitely enjoy their music and listen to it a lot like a lottt I listen to them often they have some rlly good songs and I think they have a sound and it's so unfair especially when these other groups release shit on a track the mess that was yhmah didn't help with this mess either
oo criyangis sending trucks tomorrow about his parts & styling. the parts i do get but imo his styling has been better recently
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 I saw his fans tweaking over no lines in the album sampler they just can't recognize his voice it's crazy but wow did they reach the funding goal already if they're popping out tmrw
pls no pls dont take this ricky away from me https://x.com/QualiaQuanrui/status/1820309364403782038 💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔 ill actually be so sad 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 but agree with the no lines like his tone is one of the prettiest for them not to utilize it properly unlike in ftp like take jiwoongs lines and give it to him
I think I'm understanding their point more but again a truck is so unnecessary and would also send the wrong message ugh his styling can't be nuked again there's a difference in opinion between the k and c side but idk like every other truck nothings gonna happen most likely
tbh nothing will happen unless they post the truck on twt and it gets engagement
noyb has that drafted tweet ready girl wym it's going to blow up
oh his cbar posted but they didn't mention the styling in their caption 😭 maybe they took it off the trucks i can't read korean
They had like a zillion trucks out there so idk if the message made it
is be so embarrassed if my fans did this icl, like even if it was for good reason like it’s right infront of the company door everyone and their mama will know about ny business is just have to call in sick
NGNNFNRMFMMDMDMFMMFMD and trucks do nothing bruh they airing for no reason my bad this is a late ass reply
oo criyangis sending trucks tomorrow about his parts & styling. the parts i do get but imo his styling has been better recently
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 I saw his fans tweaking over no lines in the album sampler they just can't recognize his voice it's crazy but wow did they reach the funding goal already if they're popping out tmrw
pls no pls dont take this ricky away from me https://x.com/QualiaQuanrui/status/1820309364403782038 💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔 ill actually be so sad 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 but agree with the no lines like his tone is one of the prettiest for them not to utilize it properly unlike in ftp like take jiwoongs lines and give it to him
I think I'm understanding their point more but again a truck is so unnecessary and would also send the wrong message ugh his styling can't be nuked again there's a difference in opinion between the k and c side but idk like every other truck nothings gonna happen most likely
tbh nothing will happen unless they post the truck on twt and it gets engagement
noyb has that drafted tweet ready girl wym it's going to blow up
djfkdlsjfkljsa i forgot about noyb them and ttopaz will definitely post
like let me see if they posted they're always on the scene
the era of cbar mass buying is over anyways for pretty much all kpop unless it's for solos this has been true since probably late 2023 so all the cbars not opening links is to be expected regardless of treatment ngl
yea everyone's sales have been declining this era of sales is kinda over
Didn’t someone send in here how there’s the new shipping regulations to China which have meant cbar numbers overall have gone down alot and now cbars are hiding numbers or not opening likes under the guise of doing it because of treatment but it’s really because they don’t want fans to see the drop in album orders. This is something that’s effected all groups
Yup even if we had the bars opening for us the sales wouldn't be as high in general sales in kpop have been declining
rather than the shipping regulations which could still be a factor, the biggest thing is that chinese kpop stans don't really wanna spend huge amounts on kpop groups who won't prioritize them if that makes sense? it's a widespread sentiment now across all fandoms that they'd rather spend money on flights to korea for their own stanning experience rather than for good numbers and breaking records for their idol, which i do support. you're right that many cbars are hiding numbers because they don't want there to be a public drop in orders, but that's more a result of fandom sentiment and honestly decline in number of chinese kpop stans overall than regulations also baekhyun's solo cbar orders broke 200k albums in one day just a few weeks ago so numbers can still be high, it depends on whether fans are willing to spend for it which is realistically not gonna happen for non-solo orders since solo stanning is so prevalent in china
oh for sure I can see that and it's true that while stuff is declining it's possible to upkeep numbers if you try zb1 debuted in the middle of this decline but broke records because of the effort
dance looks so much better when gunbin danced it yay
NFNRNNFNSMNDNDJDN LOWKEYYYYYYYY
it looks better but the choreo is still underwhelming imo
it is but I'm still gonna hold it in theyve said the choreo is hard and rlly good so idk
sometimes dance challenges are simplified on purpose so we’ll see
it definitely is they like stopped dancing to do something for the tiktok and I think they're actually gonna try to get a viral challenge
I hope it works for them. For example, midas touch of kiof had potential to go viral since the beginning but for some reason their company decided to simplify their tiktok dance challenge (when it was already easy) and that delayed the virality of the song on tiktok
I think this approach is good because the chorus choreo just never hit off with the challenge so I hope so too
dance looks so much better when gunbin danced it yay
NFNRNNFNSMNDNDJDN LOWKEYYYYYYYY
it looks better but the choreo is still underwhelming imo
it is but I'm still gonna hold it in theyve said the choreo is hard and rlly good so idk
It could just be that the chorus had the easier part because the vocals are so high and to make it easier for tt challanges but the rest of the choreo is harder / more dynamic. Also I always thought the chorus sounded like it was split between 2 and now I’m wondering if those are the units it’s split into
I feel like we got a clearer vision with the teaser today but it still feels like a slightly simplified version for tiktok
dance looks so much better when gunbin danced it yay
NFNRNNFNSMNDNDJDN LOWKEYYYYYYYY
it looks better but the choreo is still underwhelming imo
it is but I'm still gonna hold it in theyve said the choreo is hard and rlly good so idk
sometimes dance challenges are simplified on purpose so we’ll see
it definitely is they like stopped dancing to do something for the tiktok and I think they're actually gonna try to get a viral challenge
i dont remember if we ever have this much views for prev cb but 20k for good so bad 😭😭😭😭 things are looking up for jebes https://www.instiz.net/name_enter/93208294
These are really good numbers for instiz I can't say for sure how previous posts did but in general these r good numbers
dance looks so much better when gunbin danced it yay
NFNRNNFNSMNDNDJDN LOWKEYYYYYYYY
We had to say thank you dance line because I was really ready to kms thing the dance was ass 😭
😭😭
Do we think that the snippet is the chorus or the prechorus
chorus there's no way that's a pre chorus 😭 we here part of the pre chorus anyways
the era of cbar mass buying is over anyways for pretty much all kpop unless it's for solos this has been true since probably late 2023 so all the cbars not opening links is to be expected regardless of treatment ngl
yea everyone's sales have been declining this era of sales is kinda over
Didn’t someone send in here how there’s the new shipping regulations to China which have meant cbar numbers overall have gone down alot and now cbars are hiding numbers or not opening likes under the guise of doing it because of treatment but it’s really because they don’t want fans to see the drop in album orders. This is something that’s effected all groups
Yup even if we had the bars opening for us the sales wouldn't be as high in general sales in kpop have been declining
dance looks so much better when gunbin danced it yay
NFNRNNFNSMNDNDJDN LOWKEYYYYYYYY
it looks better but the choreo is still underwhelming imo
it is but I'm still gonna hold it in theyve said the choreo is hard and rlly good so idk
ZHANG HAO PLEASE STOP WITH THE FILLERS PLEASE STIPOP PLEASE
NNENFNMFFMBMDMDMF I like it the change is just kinda big I'm hoping it doesn't get to pillow face levels tho like let's remain calm on the filler 😫 maybe it'll settle down some more cuz it's pre cb stuff idk
lip fillers or?
jaw and chin
I know it's prob the douyin puffy lips but he got those downturned filler lips like yeonjun
oh I can see that lowkey
Oh it's the same as over here zangggg
Rosins gotta be grovelling for a fight these days I wouldn’t care but the illiteracy kills me because how are you going to shade a fanbase for raising money to buy more copies of the album to help they boys on music shows and claim they did something wrong by ordering hanbin’s digipack only when that’s exactly what they advertised on the post 😭 I don’t even speak Japanese but I can see the words digipack right there and it’s a hanbin fanbase like whose digipack did you think they meant
they're jumping the hanbin japan fanbase 😭...?
no ones even jumping anyone its just allins making a big deal of one akgae tweet again you guys are all the same looking for fights when you can just move on and ignore 😭 and its the typical discount link fanbases put out
oh damn okay this is nothing
oo criyangis sending trucks tomorrow about his parts & styling. the parts i do get but imo his styling has been better recently
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 I saw his fans tweaking over no lines in the album sampler they just can't recognize his voice it's crazy but wow did they reach the funding goal already if they're popping out tmrw
this subfandom has become so irking like what about his styling is bad??? i love it so much he's been looking good every single day like what? 😭
I guess that acc getting reported is common sentiment in China which I don't get cuz sorry Ricky looked a damn mess for almost 6 months......
i read the translations they don’t mention his clothes they wrote “is this professional hair and makeup? ricky doing it himself is better than this. Immediately improve your poor skills!” from what ive seen cfans in general hate when a lot of hairspray or that wet look is given to hair ive seen it in every fandom ive been in they think it looks greasy and idk what issue theyve had with makeup recently cuz its been looking better
I consider styling generally so I mean makeup clothes all of it. but it's actually about the makeup?? I thought it would be the sleeveless issue which would make sense since a lottt of other fans hate it for other members and Ricky definitely gets it the most. but that's ....interesting the wet look isn't too bad but genuinely Ricky has looked better now than he did months ago they rlly want him to start looking a mess again yuck
i thought abt it more and im thinking they might still be upset abt the makeup he had for keep running and some other schedules cuz big cent accounts were dragging him for heavy makeup a lot of his fans do prefer more natural makeup in certain contexts and also balloon helped them write the statements for the trucks so i guess it somewhat reflects kfan opinion too
I can agree on that they put Ricky in the heaviest makeup out of the group and I've always loved the lighter look on him but a truck 😅😅😅😅 but if balloons in on it I guess kfans agree on something maybe it's the line thing maybe it's the sleeveless styling ik they hate that too
Different aesthetic sense, all members' concept photos in the cinema were criticized on weibo because they didn't look like idols. Cfans really hate wet hair looks, that's their ick and Ricky has been constantly having wet hair and gelled it ever since he had black hair. They also hate it when idols exercise and wear tank tops
so what did they look like then.. NDNNFNFNND I mean they can go ahead they wanna nerf Ricky they can do it
Between this and that fanbase asking Anton to change his styling... This is so funny
No the Anton is way worse they're only talking ab the styling and they're blasting his Turkish hairline LIKE I WOUKD KILL MYSELF IF I HOT THAT KINDA TRUCK
Oh I haven't seen that new hairline yet... The last time I saw Anton was like 5 months ago, sorry we really dislike riize over here 😂
lotus is my sis so I see Anton everyday
dance looks so much better when gunbin danced it yay
NFNRNNFNSMNDNDJDN LOWKEYYYYYYYY
Yesterday I asked for the main dancers and they gave us the main dancers
well yes
oo criyangis sending trucks tomorrow about his parts & styling. the parts i do get but imo his styling has been better recently
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 I saw his fans tweaking over no lines in the album sampler they just can't recognize his voice it's crazy but wow did they reach the funding goal already if they're popping out tmrw
this subfandom has become so irking like what about his styling is bad??? i love it so much he's been looking good every single day like what? 😭
I guess that acc getting reported is common sentiment in China which I don't get cuz sorry Ricky looked a damn mess for almost 6 months......
i read the translations they don’t mention his clothes they wrote “is this professional hair and makeup? ricky doing it himself is better than this. Immediately improve your poor skills!” from what ive seen cfans in general hate when a lot of hairspray or that wet look is given to hair ive seen it in every fandom ive been in they think it looks greasy and idk what issue theyve had with makeup recently cuz its been looking better
I consider styling generally so I mean makeup clothes all of it. but it's actually about the makeup?? I thought it would be the sleeveless issue which would make sense since a lottt of other fans hate it for other members and Ricky definitely gets it the most. but that's ....interesting the wet look isn't too bad but genuinely Ricky has looked better now than he did months ago they rlly want him to start looking a mess again yuck
i thought abt it more and im thinking they might still be upset abt the makeup he had for keep running and some other schedules cuz big cent accounts were dragging him for heavy makeup a lot of his fans do prefer more natural makeup in certain contexts and also balloon helped them write the statements for the trucks so i guess it somewhat reflects kfan opinion too
I can agree on that they put Ricky in the heaviest makeup out of the group and I've always loved the lighter look on him but a truck 😅😅😅😅 but if balloons in on it I guess kfans agree on something maybe it's the line thing maybe it's the sleeveless styling ik they hate that too
Different aesthetic sense, all members' concept photos in the cinema were criticized on weibo because they didn't look like idols. Cfans really hate wet hair looks, that's their ick and Ricky has been constantly having wet hair and gelled it ever since he had black hair. They also hate it when idols exercise and wear tank tops
so what did they look like then.. NDNNFNFNND I mean they can go ahead they wanna nerf Ricky they can do it
Between this and that fanbase asking Anton to change his styling... This is so funny
No the Anton is way worse they're only talking ab the styling and they're blasting his Turkish hairline LIKE I WOUKD KILL MYSELF IF I HOT THAT KINDA TRUCK